California tax decisions tell us how a dispute ended. Briefs give us an earlier look at the questions taxpayers and the state are asking, the arguments they are making, and the issues that could become tomorrow’s important decisions.
At Hodgson Russ, we receive quarterly releases of briefs from California’s Office of Tax Appeals (OTA). With this post, we’re launching a recurring California Tax Pulse update on what those releases reveal about the disputes working their way through the OTA. This installment covers the third-quarter 2026 collection. Additional posts will follow as future quarterly releases become available.
California tax proposals have a way of attracting attention beyond California. The proposed billionaire tax is no exception—and, according to the Wall Street Journal, next week’s vote could offer an early glimpse of the debate heading into the 2028 presidential election.
Can California tax part of a nonresident’s gain from selling a partnership interest simply because federal law labels that portion ordinary income? In Appeals of Burch and Carden, 2026-OTA-527P, the Office of Tax Appeals answered no. The decision, currently designated pending precedential, rejects the Franchise Tax Board’s position in Legal Ruling 2022-02 and reinforces a distinction that can get lost in a complicated transaction: the character of income does not necessarily determine its source.
What happens when a California executive leaves the state and later receives a multimillion-dollar severance payment tied to the job he actually performed in California? According to the California Office of Tax Appeals, the answer may depend less on where he worked before leaving and more on where his contract required him to work in the future.