Just in Time for the Holidays – New York’s Advanced Nuclear Master Plan
The Nuclear Reliability Backbone White Paper just dropped in Case 26-E-0335, pending before the New York State Public Service Commission (Backbone Case). Interesting and clarifying details are beginning to emerge in Governor Hochul’s marquee energy initiative. For one thing, the Backbone is firmly scaled at 8.4 gigawatts (3.4 existing at the four legacy plants, 1 to be developed by the New York Power Authority, and 4 to be added as the process proceeds).
As to technologies, for “new advanced nuclear” to be added to New York’s generation mix, it must first and foremost be “new.” Consequently, state support “should not extend to power upgrades, life extensions, or other upgrades at the State’s existing nuclear facilities,” and is limited to “designs that improve on conventional reactors through features such as passive or inherent safety systems, modular construction, alternative coolants, and operational versatility.” Generation III+ and IV reactors are specifically encouraged in the White Paper (WP). At the same time, the WP also has positive things to say about Large Light Water Reactors and the Westinghouse AP 1000 design.
In its “Coordination and Proceeding Interaction” section, the WP acknowledges and discusses the welter of policy initiatives that bear on the Backbone Case. In its “Cost Effectiveness” section, the WP notes that 5 GWs of nuclear generation “could reduce the need to overbuild new renewable resources…by about 20 GW [and] the need for three GW of transmission investments.”
The same section refers back to the Advanced Nuclear Policy Options Paper, noting that staff estimated the cost of State support for the Backbone to range from $15.4 billion to $23.9 billion over the first 25 years of operation. In its “Safety” section, the WP opines that safety risks are likely to be manageable, and it adds a final interesting tidbit: there are about 127 casks of low-level waste stored at Indian Point and 278 canisters of vitrified high-level waste at West Valley.
The remainder of the WP focuses on Financing and Commercial Viability, Procurement, and Nuclear Pipeline and Sequencing. As to the realities of bankrolling these projects, the WP revisits the concepts of revenue support mechanisms, risk shifting to third-party off-takers, partial state cost-overrun guarantees, state or utility equity participation, and early-development-phase grants or loans. It notes that the old model of utility-owned generation “continues to be under review.”
As to the actual process required to fill the 4 GW generation order, the WP recommends establishment of a pre-qualification review and an “open book” negotiation model. As to the eventual build-out, the WP contemplates a sequential development across the State, relying on a single technology that is proven, replicable, and advanced.
In its final recommendations, the WP assigns to the Department of Public Service (DPS) and the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) some homework:
- Develop and establish a revenue support mechanism for new advanced nuclear generation.
- Develop an eligibility and pre-qualification process that can offer the opportunity for initial screening of developers, sites, project proposals, and technology readiness.
- Establish a competitive, open-book negotiation process with the cost control and risk allocation principles as described [in the WP].
- Develop a new advanced nuclear Procurement Framework and file an Implementation Plan for Commission consideration.
NYSERDA will host a public webinar on the WP at noon on January 13, 2027.
For more information, please contact William Helmer, Thomas Berkman, Daniel Spitzer, or another member of our Energy Practice.
Disclaimer
This alert is a form of attorney advertising. Hodgson Russ LLP provides this information as a service to its clients and other readers for educational purposes only. Nothing in this client alert should be construed as, or relied upon, as legal advice or as creating a lawyer-client relationship.